Africa and Live8

On the colonial imagining of Africa We all just witnessed the “historical� Live8 concerts and the huge coverage that they have received in the news; even more than the g8 summit in Edinburgh and much more than the protests organised around it. Apart from diverting attention from the latter (exactly the opposite effect to the one supposedly intended by the concert), some other reflections seem in order. First, how the traditionally confronting style of the protests of the alter-globalisation movement has been wiped off the picture. In Edinburgh, the news showed us huge numbers of disciplined people in rosy marches, with banners bearing the same bourgeois slogans that the concerts have popularised: fair trade, make poverty history, care for Africa (the far away land where the problems are supposed to be). In short, a completely apolitical framing of the problem of inequality in the world; instead of criticising the expansion of imperial plundering, the call is for more of it: more integration of the third world (and its resources) to the wealthy one, and more dependency on it. It also stroke me the ubiquity of the faces of the presidents and of the names of the g8 countries in the images of the concert. If the media and image creators would be naive, this wouldn’t be a big deal, but they aren’t. The sophistication of marketing techniques, and their careful and pervasive use, doesn’t allow thinking that this isn’t significant. What I saw was an exercise, more or less conscious, of making the g8 responsible for the fate of Africa, and in doing so, willingly or not, of making this band of crooks the legitimate embodiment of an as yet budding global government. This was complemented by the representation of Africa as kids or women. The partnership on the stage at the end of the concert, quite patronisingly, was of mainly White singers, and African children. The concert also speaks to another aspect of European society and its future: the effects of an ageing population. All the transgressive power and rebel attitude that rock’n roll used to have when these same people were young have been erased by their wealth and wrinkles. What we saw on stage and in the interviews that followed –no interviewee had an account smaller than a million quit– were some conservative folks struggling to look young through face lifts and affected slangism. They seemed to be trying to redeem, through appeals for prodigality, their lost years of profligacy. John Lennon must be thankful he was shot; he wouldn’t have been if he would’ve shared his table with super-power presidents. Imagine! What a bizarre spectacle. It would be only that if it wouldn’t resemble too closely the images and messages that followed the “boxing day� tsunami, as it’s called in England –whether parochially or colonially, I don’t know. In fact, put together parochialism, pity and a messianic drive, and you have a good recipe for colonialism. This is precisely what was cooked at the concerts.

Comments

Re: Africa and Live8

By dark red

You 're right! It's completely true that the hole movement of the singers has nothing to do with the movement the older of us remember in Woodstock and in similar movements in Europe against the Vietnam war etc. This one, is a postmodern movement that is if not completely, surely quite enough manipulated by the rulling propaganda. How do they dare to speak against the poverty, when, at the same time they are shouting "Free trade ! Free trade!!" ??? Who are they trying to befool? The hole movement of the well-paid burgoise singers and "artists" has nothing political to say. The political movements of the ruled classes have to be in the scene, despite the effort of the bourgeoise Media to disappear us. So, let's see what we can do. The exploited classes will make the poverty history, noone else can, or has the will to make it.

The facts?

By niels

wow, even your website doesn't portray reality...Wow, if you go the website that has been included a picture is posted that shows the back of the police jeep with a gun pointing out and Carlo holding a fire extinguisher in his hands at chest level. First of all I would find it VERY hard for someone to be killed or even seriously injured by throwing a fire extinguisher at them especially given the positions that are shown in the photo - the cop is in a jeep above Carlo and most importantly the extinguisher is being held at chest level, not exactly how you'd hold it in order to really injure someone with it. And secondly if someone was pointing a live gun at me I might want to try and find a way to either disarm that person or have something in front of me which MIGHT be able to slow down or deflect the bullet. I would say that if anything Carlo was just trying to disarm a stupid cop who was finally showing his true colors by taking out a deadly weapon to use against protesters. To say that the cop's life was in any way in danger is ridiculous. The cop is most likely even wearing some sort of protective clothing - though there is no way to tell in the photo...

Re: Africa and Live8

By ignacius

You're right, and they're quite effective. Look at the letter the BBC published in its webpage the day after the concerts: "Africa needs a period of 40 - 50 years of re-colonization. This time it should be done right and in such a manner that Africa is left in the same condition at the negotiated end of colonization as Europe is today. This time round the borders of the states of Africa should reflect the Geography and Ethnicity of Africa and not the shape of the coffee stains on a map in a drawing room a la Berlin conference. It is possible. But improbable given the amount of jingoistic "anti-colonialism" bandied about the capitals of Africa. John Jones, London

Re: Africa and Live8

By ignacius

You're right, and they're quite effective. Look at the letter the BBC published in its webpage the day after the concerts: "Africa needs a period of 40 - 50 years of re-colonization. This time it should be done right and in such a manner that Africa is left in the same condition at the negotiated end of colonization as Europe is today. This time round the borders of the states of Africa should reflect the Geography and Ethnicity of Africa and not the shape of the coffee stains on a map in a drawing room a la Berlin conference. It is possible. But improbable given the amount of jingoistic "anti-colonialism" bandied about the capitals of Africa. John Jones, London

Create an account or log in to post your article or announce an event

randomness